Before we fully dive into the new year and our new selves, let’s take one last look at 2023 — specifically the last 31 days of 2023. Every month, the Refinery29 Shopping team takes a gander at our anonymous shopping data to see what put a twinkle in readers’ eyes. In December, it was — you guessed it — holiday gift after holiday gift. These presents purposely pegged to the yuletide are, however, timeless, me-myself-and-I buys. At least, we think so.
That limited-edition Brightland olive oil set you bought for your cousin? It’s time to order it for yourself. The plush Madewell sweater you scored for your sister? Perhaps, it’s worth adding to your own cart. That’s right, the holidays are over, and your budget’s priorities are back in the right order. After all your holiday generosity, it’s time to treat yourself to something nice to ring in the new year — whether it’s a bestselling personalized planner, a cozy Free People onesie, an orgasmic Tracy’s Dog gadget, or a brand-new bed frame. So scroll on for 29 top-bought, reader-favorite gifts products from the month of December. And, yes, make sure to fill in your very own shipping address.
At Refinery29, we’re here to help you navigate this overwhelming world of stuff. All of our market picks are independently selected and curated by the editorial team. If you buy something we link to on our site, Refinery29 may earn commission.
For more can’t-miss shopping stories delivered straight to your inbox, sign up for our Most Wanted newsletter.
Another month, another cozy sweatsuit stealing Refinery29 readers’ hearts. Free People’s relaxed-fit onesie is the ultimate lazy-day ‘fit. And we can’t forget about the flattering circle cut out in the back.
Shop Free People
Free People Settle Down Onesie, $, available at Free People
Happy new year! Start 2024 off right with one of Refinery29 readers’ all-time favorite planners available on Etsy.
Shop Etsy
KubikGe 2023-2024 Personalized Planner, $, available at Etsy
And while you’re at it, why not pick up this colorful pack of pens while you wait for your equally adorable planner?
Shop Amazon
Sakura Gelly Roll Gel Pens 10 Pack, $, available at Amazon
According to our Gen Z editors and plenty of Refinery29 shoppers, this floral trinket makes an excellent gift (for the holidays and beyond).
Shop Etsy
AlmarilloCreations 6-Inch Pressed Flower Resin Letter, $, available at Etsy
Last year, our former deals writer Mercedes Viera gave Avocado’s organic latex mattress a major thumbs-up. Now, readers are scoring the brand’s sleek bed frame (no tools required for assembly!).
Shop Avocado Mattress
Avocado City Bed Frame, $, available at Avocado
In December, we hunted down the best party-dress-and-shoe combos to help you survive the annual onslaught of holiday shindigs. The bell of the ball? Ganni’s chic and comfy kicks that pair perfectly with cozy knitwear.
Shop Net-A-Porter
Ganni Buckled Eyelet-Embellished Faux Leather Ballet Flats, $, available at Net-A-Porter
You’re sure to fulfill your 2024 reading resolution with these lovable, bestselling bookmarks.
Shop Amazon
Outus Cute Dogs Magnetic Bookmarks, 30 Pieces, $, available at Amazon
For those who adore multifaceted furniture and easy assembly, check out December’s top-bought loveseat: Burrow’s compact modular sofa.
Shop Burrow
Burrow Range 2-Piece One Arm Sofa With Table, $, available at Burrow
Calling all candle lovers! This accessory set — featuring a wick trimmer, snuffer, and dipper — is made for you.
Shop Amazon
Calary Candle Wick Trimmer, Snuffer & Wick Dipper Set, $, available at Amazon
Luxury is a state of mind, not a dollar sign. This A&F coat, for example, features trendy quilted stitching and more unique detailing to exude a high-end feel minus the high-end price tag. If you’re looking to treat the stylish man in your life to something nice, give this under-$100 luxury find a try.
Shop Abercrombie & Fitch
Abercrombie & Fitch Quilted Liner Jacket, $, available at Abercrombie & Fitch
Stimulate blood circulation, alleviate sore feet, and de-stress after a long day on your toes with this therapeutic wooden massager.
Shop Amazon
TheraFlow Foot Massager, $, available at Amazon
A cozy, plush crewneck sweater that looks as good as it feels.
Shop Madewell
Madewell Brushed Checkerboard Fair Isle Oversized Sweater, $, available at Madewell
Tracy’s Dog’s orgasmic gadgets consistently make their way into Refinery29 readers’ carts — whether it’s the brand’s classic OG Flow or this under-$50, clit-sucking vibe. One satisfied Tracy’s Dog reviewer mentions, “Honestly, it’s the best clit sucker ever, and I’ve tried them all. The head also vibrates, and it’s amazing.”
Shop Tracy’s Dog
Tracy’s Dog P. Cat Sucking Vibrator, $, available at tracy’s dog
Turns out, the best gift for Dad isn’t a grill set, shaving kit, or poker game bundle — it’s actually a box of 80 cards to help him describe every one of his feelings.
Shop Amazon
Therese Vandling, Tiffany Watt Smith Box Of Emotions, $, available at Amazon
Lelo’s price tags are high but so are the brand’s breathtaking sex tech buys. The Lily 3 is equipped with 10 powerful settings, an ergonomic design, supple silicone, and more innovative features for intense pleasure all in the palm of your hand.
Shop Lelo
LELO Lily 3, $, available at LELO
This couch takes the phrase “sit back and relax” to a whole new level. Thanks to its fold-out function, this East Urban Home’s sleeper sofa transforms into a 40-inch wide bed — whichever room you place it in, you get the best of both worlds. Plus, according to Wayfair reviewer Tanya, it’s “perfect if some[one] spends the night,” and it’s “comfortable to sit on and very easy to put together.”
Shop Wayfair
East Urban Home Upholstered, $, available at Wayfair
Designed with breathable mesh, an adjustable backrest, lumbar support, and more, this under-$200 seat is the definition of a practical purchase.
Shop Wayfair
Ebern Designs Siyer Ergonomic Mesh Task Chair, $, available at Wayfair
People love boyfriend jeans for plenty of reasons. For one, their relaxed, masculine silhouettes keep things comfy all while exuding a chic, laid-back allure. Want in on the trend? We wholeheartedly suggest scoring this reader-favorite pair from Nordstrom — especially while it’s on supersale (and still in stock).
Shop Nordstrom
AG Ex-Boyfriend Ripped Jeans, $, available at Nordstrom
This rosy, top-rated nail polish set is ideal for gifting, pedicures, and everyday wear — based on on-site Sephora reviewers, that is.
Shop Sephora
Deborah Lippmann Bed of Roses Nail Polish Set, $, available at Sephora
A bed dressed in Boll & Branch sheets is a bed worth sleeping in. The brand’s signature set was the apple of many readers’ eyes in December — blame it on its buttery-soft, organic cotton, deep fitted sheet pockets, luxe colorways, or any of these threads top-notch specs.
Shop Boll & Branch
Boll & Branch Signature Hemmed Sheet Set, $, available at Boll & Branch
We’ll let you in on a little secret: The best Amazon stocking stuffers are under $25 and, more importantly, worth buying year-round. We scouted this nifty tool in the online marketplace’s massive inventory. ‘Tis a lifesaver for putting on finicky pieces of jewelry by yourself.
Shop Amazon
Miles Kimball Bracelet Fastener Helper Tool, $, available at Amazon
Three top-rated oil blends with jasmine and eucalyptus scents. Readers added tons to their December shopping carts — whether it was for loved ones or surviving holiday hysteria.
Shop Amazon
Benatu Essential Oil Roll-On Set, $, available at Amazon
While Brightland’s classic olive oil and vinegar duo will always have a place in our hearts, we had our eyes on the brand’s merry and bright citrus set in December. It features Brightland’s Awake extra-virgin olive oil, Parasol citrus-champagne vinegar, orange blossom honey, and a handy pouring spout for the olive oil bottle. We deemed it an excellent practical gift, but, of course, it’d look dashing in your pantry and taste amazing in your dishes.
Shop Nordstrom
Brightland Luminous 4-Piece Set, $, available at Nordstrom
TikTok GRWM videos revolutionized makeup and skin-care routines as we know them. Now, you’ll find all kinds of adorable accessories, such as these fluffy bunny bands that look great on camera and keep hair out of the way during daily regimens.
Shop Amazon
Ygreato Bunny Ears Elastic Makeup Headbands, 4-Pack, $, available at Amazon
Last month, a few members of the R29 Shopping team divulged their favorite buys from the popular MTC marketplace Quince. According to our sex and wellness writer, Charlotte Lewis, the retailer’s Organic Embroidered Sheet Set is the one to beat. “I am a really bad sleeper with a ton of sensory issues, so changing up sheets is always a bit of a risk for me,” she writes. “Newly washed sheets always feel great, but even after a week of sleeping on them, the Quince sheets remained soft, crisp, and fresh because they’re so breathable. They’ve been washed multiple times, have seen zero signs of wear or pilling, and, honestly, I can’t believe how affordable they are given how much they feel like my best sheet set (literally they’re one-third of the price).”
Shop Quince
Quince Luxury Organic Sateen Embroidered Sheet Set, $, available at Quince
According to its on-site description, this hair oil creates stronger curls, reduces breakage, minimizes frizz, and more. According to our anonymous shopping data, Refinery29 readers can’t get enough of it.
Shop Amazon
Kérastase Discipline Oleo-Relax Advanced Hair Oil, $, available at Amazon
Introducing the coziest, under-$50 slipper around. Readers snatched up quite a few to keep their toes toasty all winter long, and we think you should, too.
Shop Nordstrom Rack
Minnetonka Sondra Faux Shearling Slipper, $, available at Nordstrom Rack
Nordstrom Rack’s deals cup runneth over with discounts we can’t ignore. This refurbished Dyson beauty tech, for example, is engineered for all hair types, and it’s on sale for an impressive 60% off.
Shop Nordstrom Rack
Dyson Corrale™ Straightener Black Nickel/Fuchsia – Refurbishe, $, available at Nordstrom Rack
Milk Bar always has a little somethin’ somethin’ for even the most insatiable sweet tooth. This party pack includes one Assorted Cookie Tin, B’Day Cake Truffle Dozen Box, and Chocolate B’Day Cake Truffle Dozen Box.
Shop Milk Bar
Milk Bar The Little Somethings, $, available at Milk Bar
Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?
29 Top-Bought Reader Products From November
You ask, we answer! @_lorettathomas says, “Hi inquiring minds would like to know where can…
Naomi Campbell isn’t the only one pulling out archive dresses from her collection as Jada…
Noticeably absent from this year’s MET Gala, Rihanna and A$AP Rocky were spotted out on…
Award-winning artist Mary J. Blige, who is known for her cutting edge boots has officially…
We’ve raved about Lululemon plenty on this site — and it’s genuinely because we’re fans…
.disclaimer{width:90%;margin-bottom:1rem}.disclaimer__lines{width:100%;margin:0 auto;border-bottom:1px solid #999;padding:0;max-width:150px}.disclaimer__copy{width:100%;max-width:355px;font-family:Brown Regular,sans-serif;font-size:.9rem;font-weight:300;line-height:1.3em;color:#333;padding:0 0 .4rem;margin:1rem auto;text-align:center} All linked products are independently selected by…